Those 'official' numbers were probably very unreliable.

送交者: LB 于 2013-10-29, 15:28:16:

回答: Data interpretation for Dummies - how to explain Liaoning's death rate. 由 steven 于 2013-10-29, 11:44:45:

Staying in this forum for so long, you must know the Chinese way with numbers. Don't so cynical when seeing somebody questioning the famine. Not all of them are defending CCP.

FYI: the population of Liaoning is about 40 million. How many Russian dead bodies you need to make that death rate? Do the math yourself.

所有跟贴:

If you have concern regarding the accuracy, please contact CCP. (无内容) - steven (0 bytes) 2013-10-29, 16:30:38 (730980)
- I dare you say the same thing to this guy. - LB (145 bytes) 2013-10-29, 16:38:26 (730981)
  - 我想共产党的保险箱里面一定有比较准确的数据，只是不想公开罢了 (无内容) - conner (0 bytes) 2013-10-29, 22:37:01 (731001)
    - 曾经听过西方评论有关中国人口，有人认为50年代中国的人口没那么多。 - steven (74 bytes) 2013-10-30, 02:00:00 (731017)
      - 几十年的人口数字都有人口普查数据互相印证，哪有你听说的那回事。 (无内容) - Amsel (0 bytes) 2013-10-30, 23:14:20 (731053)
        
        Cressey, George B. Land of the 500 Million, p. 9. 1955. - steven (62 bytes) 2013-10-31, 12:24:57 (731085)
  - 你认为他的倒数第四段靠谱吗？ (无内容) - xname4 (0 bytes) 2013-10-29, 16:56:14 (730983)
    - No. Chinese had only one way to die. - LB (14 bytes) 2013-10-29, 19:41:32 (730988)
      - It is fair to say the paper I quote was from a minor journal - steven (1388 bytes) 2013-10-29, 20:52:44 (730990)
        
        I question those numbers not because they are too high, - LB (828 bytes) 2013-10-29, 21:57:19 (730992)
        
        I know, but again, Heiti's was lower than Japan and the US also - steven (394 bytes) 2013-10-30, 01:56:16 (731016)
  - I told you I didn't come up with the number. - steven (81 bytes) 2013-10-29, 16:55:09 (730982)
    - I don't have problem that those numbers are problematic. (无内容) - LB (0 bytes) 2013-10-29, 17:02:10 (730985)

加跟贴